Monday, November 08, 2010

Follow up to last week's fake food post

I just wanted to do a quick follow up to my last post to address some of your questions and some of the things I overlooked...

First of all, thank you to all of you who recommended "The End of Overeating". I already read and *loved* this book. I strongly encourage every one of you out there to read it.

Other books I have read in the last 2 years and highly recommend:
  • "Shangrila Diet" (this book is the only 'gimicky' one of the bunch, but I credit it with my thoughts about taste-association connection and reframing my thoughts on why I was eating)
  • "Women Food and God" (Many of you suggest this book to me, but one of my favorite bloggers on earth sent me it a few months ago and I already read it. I really enjoyed it and have been meaning to re-read it)
  • "Skinny Bitch" (These gals tell it like it is. No real - or fake - sugar coating. A quick & easy read. "If you can't take one more day of self-loathing, you're ready to hear the truth: You cannot keep shoveling the same crap into your mouth every day and expect to lose weight.")
  • "Mindless Eating" (I loved the scientific nature of this book - the labs and results - it was fascinating. And they illustrated how something as simple as a description or the shape of a glass can affect what we eat. Learning tricks that are used to make us eat MORE can actually teach us how to consume less.)
  • "Fast Food Nation" (a pretty terrifying look at the fast food industry)
On a related note, I highly recommend watching the movie Food, Inc. And for what it's worth, I could not get through The Omnivore's Dilemma. I mentioned that here a few times - how I stopped at the corn section that felt like it would never end and I have been unable to pick it up since. Sorry, Pollan fans. I just don't think I can do it...
    As for my own personal transition - As soon as I decided I was no longer going to ingest fake stuff, I threw out everything in my apartment that had fake ingredients - microwave popcorn, all my bread products, many packages of gum, Weight Watchers bars, frozen yogurt, light pancake syrup, Fiber One, Crystal Light, rainbow sprinkles - I'm sure there was plenty more. I don't even remember what else I had at the time. But I got rid of it all. It was no longer going to be put into my body.

    Believe it or not, That was the easy part.

    The harder part was then looking at every single thing I bought because I no longer knew which bread was "safe". Which tortillas were "safe". Which cereal was "safe". That part took a little longer.

    I remember when I first started this huge change - I was in my Key Food supermarket - where, up until that time, I had done the majority of my shopping. I was now no longer mindlessly grabbing the Fiber One because I could have 1/2 cup for no points; I was suddenly checking every "healthy cereal" box - and my priority was no longer trying to get the most food for the least points. Now I was concerned with what I was eating. And for the first time, points weren't the leading factor in my choice - I was willing to spend 2 points to eat real food for the first time. But nearly every box I picked up had 12 lines of ingredients - many of which I didn't recognize and some of which were fake. I didn't buy any cereal.

    I remember moving onto the bread aisle and this task was no easier. Surely my Arnold's sandwich thins, which I loved and were only 1 point each, were safe? Nope, they also had unnatural ingredients (sucralose was the ingredient that jumped out at me, but there were many I could not identify). And don't even get me started on tortillas - that should be easy, right? Nope. Take a look at what's in your Mission tortillas. I bet you don't know half the items in that list.

    Shopping was suddenly a chore. But I quickly figured out how to make it easier: Stop shopping at regular supermarkets. I started doing all of my shopping at local organic healthy independent stores. And I also shop at Whole Foods.

    Now, I know some people hate Whole Foods for whatever reason. I'm not here to discuss politics or try to get you to shop there. I will say that I like them because they have a great selection of local, organic, vegan & vegetarian items. And what I love about them is that they do a lot of the work - they don't sell items with ingredients they deem unacceptable.

    So if you are thinking of phasing out some unnecessary artificial ingredients or foods, just know it can be done. And hopefully, some of what I wrote about will help you do it. Also, don't overwhelm yourself - Realize you don't need to do it all at once like I did. There is nothing wrong with making small changes at a time in a way that's realistic for you. But I'd suggest you start by looking at the ingredients of all the things you eat regularly and decide which ones you want to replace with an all-natural version. You can phase things out by replacing them with new versions as you run out or pick 1 or 2 items a week to swap - whatever you want to do and whatever works for you. But be patient, and keep in mind that you will likely be reading a lot of labels for a while and you may not like the first replacement item you buy. But you shouldn't give up - try another one. (For the record, Whole Foods takes back any food item - except beer - for a full refund if you do not like it)

    Believe it or not, the only difficult thing for me to give up in this whole transition was gum. Yes, chewing gum. I used to eat about a half a pack of Orbit Sweet Mint gum a day. If I wasn't eating food, I was chewing gum. Sometimes I even fell asleep with it in my mouth. Obviously this had nothing to do with hunger - it was just a habit. And it was just a habit I had to break.

    I also want to dispute something - I have heard people say that chewing gum helps prevent you from eating because you have gum in your mouth or that it curbs your appetite. Well, I disagree on both counts. For one thing, I sometimes *still* ate when I had gum in my mouth. I'd keep it tucked in my cheek (gross, I know); or if I was eating candy, I used to enjoy wrapping the gym around the candy, then eating the candy, having it dissolve and going back to enjoying the gym. As for it curbing appetite, I disagree with that as well because in my experience, I know that tasting artificial ingredients only made me want to taste MORE artificial ingredients. It often set off a chain reaction of eating. I saw that my gum habit was making me eat, or at least crave, more bad food. Chewing gum wasn't doing anything to help me.

    When I went natural, I did try switching to a few different kinds of 'all natural' gums but they were terrible and I realized - you know what? I don't need gum. It was just an unnecessary habit. And I gave that up too.

    In a nutshell, that's how I transitioned. If you're considering transitioning, hopefully some of that will help you. And if you do make a similar change, don't be surprised if you realize that it wasn't so difficult to give up something you previously thought you couldn't live without. It might be easier than you think.

    45 comments::

    1. I am a fan of The End of Overeating, too! It really opened my eyes to how the food industry has contributed to our eating issues and desires for certain foods!

      I also agree with you on the gum! I was a major gum-chewer (and cheek tucker! HA!)and I feel it did contribute to making me hungrier and crave more artificial/sweet foods! It's such a hard habit to ditch, though. I'm slowly weaning...

      ReplyDelete
    2. Ahh you've made me want to eat more real food! Thanks!

      ReplyDelete
    3. I wanted to thank you for your blogs about artificial flavoring. It totally woke me up. I was/am PISSED that they have duped me for so long! It's amazing how if I have some celery and cherry tomatos as a snack, I am satisfied. However, if I have a 100 calories snack pack, I want 3 more! I'm (slowly) giving it all up, even my beloved I Can't Believe It's Not Butter spray. Thank you for the wake up call! I was READY!

      ReplyDelete
    4. I was wondering if you also avoid stevia? I am really on the fence about it; I like to use it in my morning cup of tea only, nothing else, but lately I have been wondering whether it's really any better than crap like Splenda. What's your take?

      ReplyDelete
    5. Thank you for posting this. For over a year now we (me, husband, 6 year old) have phased out fake food. I bake my own bread, rolls, tortillas, granola bars, etc. It's easier than people realize and I actually enjoy it.

      Reading labels is truly eye-opening, but important. I hope this inspires people to cut out the crap. I'd rather carry a little extra weight than be full of chemicals.

      ReplyDelete
    6. Excellent advice!! And thanks for all the links, I'm definitely going to be checking some of those out. I agree with you about the chewing gum thing!

      : )

      ReplyDelete
    7. Good for you on giving up the gum! I was also a huge gum-chewer, until I started taking a holistic nutrition program. I learned that gum actually stimulates your digestion and the hydrochloric acid in your stomach starts gearing up for food, in turn making you more hungry. So it is definitely a good habit to break!

      ReplyDelete
    8. This is all good information. I read your last post, too.

      I will say about the gum thing...I don't chew it to curb my appetite or to kill a sweet tooth or anything like that. I use it to feel hydrated and to regulate my breathing while working out and running. Weird, right?! I don't see myself giving that one up...it's sort of a stress relief for me while doing totally stressful things to my body! ha!

      Excellent posts, though. Tough transition!

      ReplyDelete
    9. The kids and I just made gingerbread men, including sugar and butter of course but at least natural (and it is the almost-4 year old's birthday tomorrow) but then put brightly colored icing all over it. Powdered sugar, egg white, and drops of food coloring. The package lists six different "numbers" - I have no idea what is in them. Even in my home-made food, fake strikes again.

      ReplyDelete
    10. I honestly had no idea people really ate with gum still in their mouths. That kinda grossed me out to be honest, but I totally agree with you that it doesn't suppress your appetite. I feel like it tricks my body into thinking I'm eating which makes me hungrier. I actually get hunger pangs when I chew gum for too long. But alas, I love gum. hehe I only have a couple pieces a week nowadays but I still love it.

      ReplyDelete
    11. I read The End of Overeating over a year ago, and I still often think of parts of that book...I'm a sugar addict, so the sections about how sugar (combined with fat and salt) can mess with your mind/body spoke volumes to me. (No wonder that donuts were my favorite binge food.) That book is a real eye-opener.

      Hope you're feeling better, Sheryl. It sounds like you are re-focusing your efforts on your new healthy way of life rather than weight loss - a tricky transition at times. People need just as much support when they're at goal as during the whole weight-loss process.

      I was glad to see your post today!

      ReplyDelete
    12. 1. I could not get through The Omnivore's Dilemma either! And the same part I stopped at was the corn one. However, I'm currently reading In Defense of Food and love it. If you haven't read it try that one--it's so much less scientific and written with more humor. A much easier read.

      2. You don't like Kashi cereal? I love them 'cause there's like, 5 ingredients. Perfect!

      ReplyDelete
    13. Bookmarking this for my next Amazon shopping spree. I keep meaning to buy Women, Food and God for sure.

      Clearly I have issues but your references to transitioning made me think of vampires!

      -CJ

      ReplyDelete
    14. yeay so glad you're back!
      Totally agree on the real foods post
      x

      ReplyDelete
    15. I completely agree with you on the gum. I'm trying to treat all of that stuff like it's a line of cocaine because I've noticed that once I start eating it, it's a quick slide back down to bingeville.

      ReplyDelete
    16. I am doing this!!

      Thank you so much for the advice.

      xx
      lesley

      ReplyDelete
    17. SO grateful for this post as I am trying to transition to Clean Eating, every piece of information is helpful for me. I am looking at 50 pounds lost (70 to go) this week following Weight Watchers and the last few months I have really eliminated a lot of "Fake food" but it is mind boggling for me and every day I learn a little more. Thank you!!

      ReplyDelete
    18. I did love the omnivore's dilemma (true the corn went on and on like the fields in Nebraska lol) - the path to this way of eating, for me, was led by the ethics/moral issues: the abuse of animals/factory farming/industrialized food... I am new to this path but the idea of eating food that comes from Peru (beautiful frozen asparagus from Trader Joes), or whereever, as they sell at Whole Foods - at whatever cost (petroleum to ship) is still an issue. Eat seasonally and leave the oranges in Chile until January! This too is important, very important.

      ReplyDelete
    19. I'm in that transition now where I am trying to phase out products with unnatural ingredients and the only thing I truly miss is my Coffee-Mate Hazelnut creamer... god... that used to make my morning..

      ReplyDelete
    20. We've been changing tons too. If you're interested I have a vegan bread recipe that is super simple, and I make it every week. Just yesterday, I changed the flours to flax seed meal, whole wheat, and a little unbleached all purpose, then threw in a ton of Italian herbs that I dried from the garden. Now, when the husband gets bread from the store he tells me how artificial it tastes. =)

      LPM

      ReplyDelete
    21. I've always said that chewing gum made me hungry. I thought it was the chewing action that triggered my brain into thinking I should have food in my stomach. I never thought it might be the artificial ingrediants! But I also normally only chew it to freshen my breath.

      ReplyDelete
    22. I like your typo of wrapping the "gym" around the candy, and going back to enjoying the "gym". Excellent. Your true feelings.

      ReplyDelete
    23. I've wondered about that theory myself.
      In my experience gum just activates the acids in my stomach and convinces my body that I'm starving to death.

      ReplyDelete
    24. I was doing really good switching over to more natural foods about a year ago, but I was not watching my portions and I ended up eating way too much of these natural foods. Natural is NOT low fat, and I found that out the hard way.

      When I joined WW 3 months ago, I started seeking out all these fat free foods and snacks (fiber one bars, fat free cheese, etc) and although I am losing weight, I am eating the worst, most processed foods. Now that I am getting the hang of WW, and losing weight, I am starting to seek out more of those natural foods that will fit in my new lifestyle. Thanks for your blog post, it is inspirational to know that someone else is doing the natural thing and doing it within the WW guidelines :D

      ReplyDelete
    25. I love your blog-that's why I gave you a blog award! Go to my newest post on my blog, comment and follow the blog rules! :) Congrats!

      ReplyDelete
    26. Somebody once said that you shouldn't eat anything that your grandmother wouldn't recognize as food. My grandmother was around back when frozen meat came into our lives, and she refused to eat it. My mom said she'd look at the packets of frozen meat and say, "I'm not eating that, I don't even know when it was killed."

      My mom isn't a health nut, she was just raised by two Italian immigrants who ate actual plants and animals, and the catchall category she had for things like Rice a Roni, Hamburger Helper, and Kool-Aid was "crap." "We're not buying that, that's crap. Have a piece of fruit."

      ReplyDelete
    27. I'm in the process of making the move to natural as well. It's kind of hard with the kids though, I'm learning to do this S-L-O-W-L-Y, and for me that's OK. Not sure what I'm going to miss most, but I do know my taste buds will change as will those of the rest of the family. But I've been making this change before WW b/c my son is ADD, and well eliminating HFCS helps him so we're in this together as a family. Thanks for the post and the encouragement :)

      ReplyDelete
    28. Today I ate "lite" wasa toast and laughing cow cheese spread for lunch at work. I hadn't had either for a while, and was surprised at how weird they tasted - there was a very processed flavor to the cheese in particular. Half an hour later, I decided that I was still hungry. Since I had the WW points, I ate another serving. And I still wasn't satisfied, much less than I think I would have been with a smaller portion of (real) cheese and crackers.
      I don't know if I would have noticed this if not for the recent posts on fake food, but it's given me a lot to think about..
      - Jen (new reader)

      ReplyDelete
    29. My book recommendation is The China Study -- had a huge impact on my eating, moving away from animal products for so many reasons. I also really enjoyed Dominion, if you're interested, a little more religious but for many, being vegetarian and cruelty-free is a very spiritual/religious thing. I also have struggled with Omnivore's Dilemma for quite some time!

      ReplyDelete
    30. Wow Janis! That's a great quote. I have always wondered what my Cuban grandmother would think of my vegetarianism. I assume it's something along the lines of My Big Fat Greek Wedding when the aunt goes "He don't eat no meat? That's ok, I'll make lamb"

      ReplyDelete
    31. Thanks for the post and the references. The only thing I've left behind already is diet soda, but I'm moving toward foods with ingredients that don't require my chemistry background.

      ReplyDelete
    32. Would it be possible to make a list of items you use on a regular basis. Such as breads, crackers, tortilla and so on. I live in a area with little to offer as far as health food stores. No Trader Joe's:(. Whole foods is almost an hour away by car. A list would save me hours in whole foods when I'm able to get there. You should see my suitcase when I come back from Virginia after visiting family. First stop is Trader Joe's as soon as I get out of the airport. My dad has stopped asking where I want to go first. He just drives to Trader Joe's and patiently deals with me while I shop. For several hours mind you. I love that place.

      Debbie L

      ReplyDelete
    33. For me, as a recovering bulimic, it is so important to know that the food I put into my body is food that will nourish it, fuel it, FEED it in the way I refused to allow it to do for so long. I wholeheartedly agree with you on the importance of eating real food. Since I became more conscientious about "clean eating" over the summer, I can't believe how much easier it is to manage cravings, and to read my hunger and satiety cues correctly. And I wasn't eating much junk to begin with! This evening, I had a square of dark chocolate, and a bowl of roasted carrots for a snack, when last winter I would have been rooting around for all the packaged food I could find. I feel satisfied. (I feel awesome.)

      ReplyDelete
    34. Thanks for these recommendations. I've had the End of Overeating for a little while but haven't read it yet. I also stopped reading Omnivore's Dilemma during the corn section. I just couldn't bear to continue reading! I've been wanting to break my fake food addiction but I haven't had that "click" moment you speak of yet where I just reject it. But I do think a step by step elimination process...starting with my crystal light addiction...

      ReplyDelete
    35. I totally aggree with you. I find that eating "real" food satisfies me. I stay full and feel better.
      As a biochemist I read some of the ingredients on labels and shudder...it's difficult to eat completely natural, but well worth the effort I find. And once you lose the taste for the "fake" foods...well, they taste fake. You can't go back. :)

      ReplyDelete
    36. Two other books you should consider reading are:
      Sugar Shock & Twinkie Deconstructed. They both touch on the crap companies put in our food and how our bodies react to it.

      ReplyDelete
    37. OMG, I chew orbit sweet mint all of the time. I never looked at the way you put it above. I defintely have to rethink the gum...

      ReplyDelete
    38. Hi Debbie, I want to point you to this post:

      http://msbitchcakes.blogspot.com/2010/09/weekly-meeting-topic-food-shopping.html

      but I will mention specifically that for bread, I buy a brand called "Matthew's" or "Vermont Bread". Tortillas are usually Whole Foods brand, but occasionally I can find some at my local stores (I have to check the ingredients of every brand. I don't know the brand names off hand because I don't always get the same kind - I seriously turn them over and look at the ingredients, not even looking at the name.) I actually don't eat crackers. Just not a fan.

      ReplyDelete
    39. Thank you for the book recommendations - I have heard lots of good things about "Women Food and God" and it, along with "The End of Overeating" are now officially on my "to read" list. My life changing book was "The China Study." It is very scientific yet surprisingly easy to read and really made me consider the effect of my food choices on the health and well-being of my body.

      ReplyDelete
    40. So true, it's so hard to buy food that isn't 'fake'. You just end up making everything yourself, from scratch at home and it can get to be such a drag. But now if we go out and eat a meal prepared by someone else, or eat snacks at a party I regret it for days afterwards. I can't believe the reaction in my stomach! I just make everything myself at home, at least I know what's in it so I can't get away with ignoring the contents.

      ReplyDelete
    41. Out of curiosity, does anyone find it somewhat financially straining buying these healthy alternatives to processed foods (breads, tortillas, etc)? I'm on a pretty strict budget and am making the transition towards eating REAL FOOD only, and replacing grain items has been pretty expensive. I don't dislike Whole Foods, but I do often refer to it as "Whole Paycheck" because of how expensive it is! Keep in mind I'm used to shopping w/ coupons and whatever is on sale, and buying most of my staple foods at Aldi (NOT healthy..but Very Cheap) Thoughts anyone?

      ReplyDelete
    42. hi, not commented for a while, if you can you should also check out the book called "The Harcombe Diet" by Zoe Harcombe, which is basically about cutting out all processed foods and killing off any bad stuff that these help to nuture inside you! She does slate weight watchers quite a bit, but its a good read. She's also brought out another one called The Obesity Epidemic but I haven't got to that one yet.

      ReplyDelete
    43. Sweet mint was my fav too. I just don't chew it anymore. Did you ever answer a readers question about Stevia? One thing that really helped me when shopping was the realization (in the store) that everything in the middle isles is made from everything on the outside isles... Epiphany. And, as a wanna be vegan I started checking out the dried beans. Talk about cheap!!!! Also, in case you don't know, the guy whom wrote "Eat this not that" has awesome tweets.

      ReplyDelete
    44. Do you know a good program or site that I can enter my recipe and it figures out cals, fat, etc? TY.

      ReplyDelete
    45. I am SO enjoying your blog!! For me, when I have done WW in the past - it turns unhealthy quickly...i.e. 10 points worth of fat free sugar free fudgicles at night after a meager dinner...none of it being satisfying...trying to to fill real needs with fake food.

      Some of the books that have helped me the most on my journey are When you Eat at the Refrigerator, Pull up a Chair by Geneen Roth and more recently A Course in Weight Loss by Marianne Williamson. Weight Watchers helps me stay mindful about what I am eating rather than unconsciously trying to fill emotional hunger with junk food. Thanks for sharing your story <3

      ReplyDelete